Homeowner guide
Contractor Quote Comparison Checklist
Direct answer: Use this checklist to compare three contractor quotes against the same project information. Record scope coverage first, then cost and contract risk. Mark missing answers as “Not stated” rather than zero, request material clarifications in writing, and keep this web checklist distinct from the original eight-page Quick-Start Homeowner Toolkit.
Key takeaways
- This is a web adaptation derived from the verified Toolkit—not a replacement for the original PDF.
- Enter what the written quote says; do not guess.
- Compare each scope line across contractors before comparing totals.
- Keep allowance, exclusion, owner purchase, and unresolved-cost rows separate.
- Confirm local credential and permit information through official sources.
Before entering quotes
- Each contractor received substantially the same dated scope, photos, selections, and updates.
- Rooms, project goals, must-have work, optional work, and known conditions are recorded.
- Site access, parking, storage, occupancy, pets, work hours, and timing limits were disclosed consistently.
- Each bidder had a comparable opportunity to inspect the project.
Scope comparison
Use Included, Excluded, Allowance, Optional, Owner-purchased, By others, or Not stated.
| Comparison row | Contractor A | Contractor B | Contractor C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quoted price | |||
| Scope description provided | |||
| Demolition | |||
| Hauling and disposal | |||
| Site and finish protection | |||
| Existing-condition repairs | |||
| Permit responsibility | |||
| Inspection fees | |||
| Labor and materials | |||
| Product brands or standards | |||
| Owner-supplied items | |||
| Patching, transitions, and cleanup | |||
| Warranty | |||
| Major exclusions |
Cost and contract-risk comparison
| Risk row | Contractor A | Contractor B | Contractor C |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allowance amount and basis | |||
| Unpriced or optional work | |||
| Unit prices, taxes, and fees | |||
| Payment schedule and deposit | |||
| Change-order markup and approval | |||
| Start conditions and duration | |||
| Delay responsibility | |||
| Proposal expiration | |||
| Insurance evidence | |||
| License or registration verification, where applicable | |||
| Documented comparable total | |||
| Questions still unanswered |
Decision checklist
- Necessary excluded work has a responsible party and written price or remains unresolved.
- Allowance basis, labor, markup, overage, and credit treatment are clear.
- Owner-purchased items include quantity, compatibility, delivery, storage, installation, and warranty responsibility.
- Schedule wording identifies start prerequisites and decision deadlines.
- Payment, change, warranty, and closeout terms were compared.
- Business information was verified through the correct official system.
- Material clarifications were incorporated into the final proposal or contract set.
Warning signs and common mistakes
Do not use a checkmark to hide weak wording. Add a note explaining the basis. Do not average unknown costs, score a contractor into acceptability despite a serious unresolved issue, or present the comparison as a professional estimate.
Questions for unresolved rows
- Is this item included in the quoted price?
- What work is specifically excluded?
- What assumption was used?
- Which products or quantities are allowances?
- Who handles permits, inspections, and related fees?
- What change and schedule process applies?
Example — illustrative only
Contractor A lists final cleaning, Contractor B lists daily protection and final cleaning, and Contractor C says nothing about cleanup. Enter Included, Included, and Not stated; do not enter three checkmarks. Ask Contractor C for written clarification before comparing the row.
Original Toolkit connection
This web checklist derives from pages 5 and 6 of the actual eight-page Quick-Start Homeowner Toolkit. It does not modify, rename, or replace that file. Use the original printable resource at protect-your-money-guide.wjlov22.workers.dev.
Book connection
Chapters 5 and 6 of Protect Your Money Before You Sign explain how to build and interpret the comparison. The verified Amazon page is available after the checklist.
Authoritative sources
- FTC — How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam, accessed November 4, 2026.
- California CSLB — Finding the Right Contractor, accessed November 4, 2026. California rules are examples only.
- Washington L&I — Hire Smart Step-by-Step, accessed November 4, 2026.
State and local variation
Credential, permit, deposit, payment, cancellation, lien, disclosure, and insurance requirements vary. Add the official checks that apply to the property location; do not transplant another state's rule.
Educational-information disclaimer
This checklist is an organizational tool, not a bid evaluation, estimate, contractor endorsement, legal review, or guarantee of cost or performance.
FAQs
May I change the rows?
Yes. Add project-specific rows without deleting material scope or risk questions.
Should contractors fill out this checklist?
They may use their own format. The homeowner can transfer written answers and ask for confirmation of material interpretations.
Does the lowest comparable total win?
No. Also review verification, clarity, experience, schedule, communication, contract terms, warranty, and serious unresolved risks.
Is this the full companion Toolkit?
No. It is a web checklist derived from selected rows. The original eight-page printable Toolkit remains separately identified and linked.
Last reviewed: November 4, 2026